Physicians FormulaRosé All Day Mascara Black Volumizing, Hypoallergenic, Conditioning, Nourishing, Lifting, Lengthening, Dermatologist Approved

Bought because of an influencer, SMLx0. But I wasn’t impressed with the formula, it’s very dry going on but takes forever to dry and feels heavy and sticky. I also didn’t see any big difference compared to other mascaras. It also is HEAVILY scented of roses which I wasn’t expecting a mascara to have. For this reason, I had to return it.

I agree with other reviewers in that yes, the formula is extremely hard to get off your skin when you make a boo boo and it is a very thin, almost watery consistency. I really hate when it just doesn't easily come off with a q-tip and you have to really rub your eye, thus jacking up your makeup. The only thing I do like about it is the scent as I adore anything Rose's but I would not purchase this again.

I first found this in CVS and purchased it on a whim. I'm so glad I did. It's water resistant but not so much that it's difficult to remove. It goes on wonderfully and reallly lengthens and thickens lashes, (not into wearing false eyelashes, just mascara), and has a really nice, very light scent to it. It does not irritate my eyes and as mentioned, comes off easily with make up remover wipes, (or whatever you use). I've had watery eyes due to allergies and this doesn't run. Very glad to have found it on Amazon. I think they were out of it at CVS. Hopefully they're still carrying it. It's great.

Best smelling mascara I've ever tried. Stays much better than others. A little difficult to remove with face wash and water, but a lil oil and it wipes off. I will buy again.

The smell is amazing, this is the first mascara i have that actually "smells" good. Makes lashes pop out. The only thing I didn't like is that it stings my eyes at times.

Wears off pretty quickly, does not make for thick lashes, but it also doesn't clump so that is a good thing.

I love Physicians Formula mascaras these are my go to. I haven’t found another affordable brand that gives great coverage without lots of clumping. I hate mascara that clumps and glues the lashes together!!The con to this is the rose scent, it’s not strong but I’m not a fan of anything that is rose scented.But regardless....this mascara is a win overall for me!

The first tube I bought at CVS Pharmacy, I loved that I could catch a light fragrance of roses from my eyelashes all day. So I bought this second one from Amazon just because of that, but the fragrance does not stay. Dissapointed. Will move back to some other mascara.