Cloud StarCrunchy Tricky Trainers 3 Flavor Variety Dog Treats Bundle: (1) Cloud Star Crunchy Tricky Trainers Cheddar Flavor, (1) Cloud Star Crunchy Tricky Trainers Liver Flavor, and (1) Cloud Star

I have ordered this pack a couple of times, and each time I find several treats from all three flavors that have very sharp metal-splinters sticking out of them. I'm not sure what ingredient causes this, or if there is just a lack of quality insurance/inspection of the treats, but thats why this product is receiving 2 less stars.My dog do love them, cheddar seems to be the favorite flavor followed by salmon and liver flavor. I use these treats for a variety of things including training several tricks, basic commands, and sometimes add a couple to their food for some extra flavor.I have stopped ordering these due to the mysterious sharp splinters. Instead I buy the three pack of these treats in chewy style and they don't seem to have the splinters.

What can I say, they are small so low calories per treat, and the puppy loves them - all 3 flavors!!

Wow. My super picky Doberman liked the soft liver tricky trainers so I thought that I would try the variety of crunchy for some change. He LOVES the cheddar flavor! He wouldn't get away from the box, and when I opened them I could see why--they smell like dried cheese (think the cheese packet in Mac n cheese). Anyway, he likes all of the flavors which makes these a total win in my book since getting him to eat anything is difficult enough. They're a great size for all of the treat dispensing toys also.

The dogs love them.....a lot! That's important to them. What's important to me is that they are only 2 calories each. I dole treats out in 3's a few times a day so I'm not concerned about weight gain, which is an issue for one of my two dogs. They don't seem to have a flavor preference. I've also bought the chewy version and they love those too.

First bought these at a pet store. They are one of the few training treats that are small and crunchy enough to be eaten quickly. As anyone who has tried to train a dog knows, treats that need to be chewed take the focus away from the task at hand; you have to wait until the dog finishes before continuing. Also, these are dry so they don't leave your hands sticky.

My Dogs love this treats. I'm constantly training my GSD, the convenient packaging make it easy to carry. The treats are small and come in three different flavors keeping my dog interested in which treat he gets next. The price through Amazon is less expensive and I never run out of treats. .

Our two Jack Russell puppies love these! Highly recommended! They're small enough you can put a few in your pocket & always have on hand to treat them when they do what they're supposed to do! They can't over eat them as they're small enough to be the perfect size! They're not picky so they love all 3 of the flavors! ML

I’ve been using these (actually my dogs have) for years. There is no smell and are small so dogs can have a few and not eat too much. These are crunchy so they don’t make a mess on your clothes if you carry in your pocket. Come in three flavors. Each treat is about a half inch square.