
Richard Carrier, Ph.D., philosopher, historian, blogger, has published a number of papers in the field of ancient history and biblical studies. He has also written several books and chapters on diverse subjects, and has been blogging and speaking since 2006. He is known the world over for all the above. But here, together for the first time, are all of Dr. Carrier's peer reviewed academic journal articles in history through the year 2013, collected with his best magazine articles, research papers, and blog posts on the same subjects. Many have been uniquely revised for this publication. Others are inaccessible except through libraries or paywalls. Twenty chapters include his seminal papers on the scandal of Hitler's Table Talk, the Jerry Vardaman microletter farce, and the testimonies to Christ in Josephus, Tacitus, and Thallus, as well as Carrier's journalistic foray into ancient pyramid quackery, his work on the historical and textual errancy of the bible, and more. Review: New Information at the Right Time - The reason I gave Hitler Homer Bible Christ a five star rating is that it filled a need, exactly when I wanted the information. Carrier's new information on Hitler (and I won't give anything away) is very helpful in any discussion about Hitler. That alone made the book worth the price. Carrier also tries to keep his books as affordable as possible, and I sure appreciate that. Now that I read the review ahead of mine, my next part of the book to read is the reference to "James the brother of Jesus" in Josephus, as the reviewer said that "is fascinating detective work, and gives a very plausible account of how this passage might have been an accidental interpolation." At one time I thought Jesus might have actually existed due references about "his brother James," so I yearn for information to the contrary so I have more evidence that he was just another myth, as the many similar gods' stories before Jesus lead me to think. Thanks to Richard Carrier for putting a book out while we wait for another of his books due around April! Review: Thoughtful and well informed rsearch review - Carrier is always interesting and unlike so many bomb throwers uses footnotes and documents his points, separates them from his informed speculations
B**O
New Information at the Right Time
The reason I gave Hitler Homer Bible Christ a five star rating is that it filled a need, exactly when I wanted the information. Carrier's new information on Hitler (and I won't give anything away) is very helpful in any discussion about Hitler. That alone made the book worth the price. Carrier also tries to keep his books as affordable as possible, and I sure appreciate that. Now that I read the review ahead of mine, my next part of the book to read is the reference to "James the brother of Jesus" in Josephus, as the reviewer said that "is fascinating detective work, and gives a very plausible account of how this passage might have been an accidental interpolation." At one time I thought Jesus might have actually existed due references about "his brother James," so I yearn for information to the contrary so I have more evidence that he was just another myth, as the many similar gods' stories before Jesus lead me to think. Thanks to Richard Carrier for putting a book out while we wait for another of his books due around April!
R**Y
Thoughtful and well informed rsearch review
Carrier is always interesting and unlike so many bomb throwers uses footnotes and documents his points, separates them from his informed speculations
G**I
Slays demon haunted Ghostdom
Probably the most erudite rebuttal of superstitious dogmas and magical fables turned into mass opiates.
A**R
mortal fears and the gods produced
Historian of science, Richard Carrier is engaging, honest and knows his stuff. He tackles a big subject: the destructive idea that goes back into mortal Man’s distant past—to stories that try to redefine death in the best possible terms. Carrier gives the reader evidence for questioning the millennias-old popular idea that an all powerful, all-knowing gods existed to look after us and is looking to us for support. The evidence for gods is thin, at best, and in this age of fantastical-thinking this book is particularly important to read and its arguments passed-on.
J**L
Argument from ignorance
This is basically a publication of convenience for Carrier's readers. Everything in the book appears elsewhere, and much of it is available on the Internet. Several of the articles date back to the early 2000's, and many readers will not find them current or topical. The main reason for the book is to provide a distribution vehicle for three of Richard's articles which have recently appeared (or will be appearing) in peer reviewed journals, and which are hidden behind pay walls. Richard's esteem for these peer reviewed journals is hard for me to fathom. Most of these journals are little more than obscure venues for boring academics to meet their professional obligation to "publish or perish". In this case, I am happy to see my money go directly to worthy authors, rather than get swallowed up by these dinosaur institutions of academia. However, in this case the three featured papers are a mixed bag. The article about "Thallus and the Darkness at Christ's Death" is unlikely to be controversial among atheists: the story that the sun stood still at Christ's death, should be an easy target for debunking, and so it is. The article about the reference to "James the brother of Jesus" in Josephus is fascinating detective work, and gives a very plausible account of how this passage might have been an accidental interpolation. However, considering that access to the original autographs has been hopelessly lost, all such arguments are ultimately conjecture, however well founded. And the third article about Tacitus's account of Christian responsibility for the burning of Rome under Nero, is entirely an argument from silence. I find it completely unpersuasive, because I don't believe that all the sources he quotes are silent about Christianity; however, they wrote using irony and satire, rather than plain speech. Carrier briefly mentions the Testimonium Flavianum, and here his scholarship is astonishingly bad. Carrier seems to be unaware that the Testimonium Flavium is a pediment in a literary triptych which is a satire of Christianity. The argument is summarized in Joe Atwill's Caesar's Messiah, which is a far more worthwhile purchase than Carrier's book. Briefly stated: in the central satire, a rogue named Decius Mundus pretends to be the god Anubis, in order to trick a dignified lady named Paulina into having sex with him. Paulina and her husband laughably agree that it is no violation of her chastity to have sex with a God. However, Mundus returns on the third day to boast that he is no God, much to Paulina's chagrin. In the other pedimental satire, a woman named Fulvia is persuaded by three men to send her wealth to the Jewish temple; but in reality, the three men spend the money "for their own uses." In the first satire, Mundus is a `type' of Jesus, and (more particularly) Titus, who tricked the Christians into worshiping him as God; in the second, the three men represent St. Paul and the Romans, with their money-hungry Catholic church. The fact that the entire Testimonium Flavianum triptych was a satire of Christianity, was clearly recognized as early as the 4th century by the Christian author Hegesippus, who elaborated on the satire by having Paulina get pregnant by Mundus, thus making her more obviously a parody of the Virgin Mary. Hegesippus's satire was pointed out by Albert A. Bell in his 1976 paper "Josephus the Satirist?". Bell also mentioned that a 1927 paper by C. Pharr had fingered the Josephus passage about Paulina and Mundus as a parody of the Annunciation. Unfortunately, both those articles appeared only in peer reviewed journals, which no one ever bothers to read.
H**E
logical, rational
Carrier is the most logical, rational critic of bible history and historical methods I have read and followed. Not much here that you can't find in his other writings and on his blog posts. But all in one place.
A**S
Brilliant
I read everything I can by Dr. Carrier. This book is scholarly, rational, and very educational.
S**L
Great read and great explanations for some of the oddities ...
Great read and great explanations for some of the oddities that we find in the Bible as well as other historical writings. This gives me more leads for research and interesting food for thought.
L**L
For the enthusiast only.
This is Richard writing in full professorial mode. Some of the papers in this collection are very dry, and argued at length. They are however well argued and include extensive citations.
G**T
A welcome reference
Dr Carrier has a knack for spotting issues with history and literature which I took for granted that I "knew". I can't pretend that they are always welcome or comfortable, but they're always worth examining.
A**E
Großartig
Ich hatte das Buch ohne gute Informationen über den Inhalt gekauft in Sorge, ob es noch relevant, gut und interessant sei. Meine Sorgen haben sich nicht erfüllt. Im Gegenteil: Ich bin total begeistert. Für Interessierte hier das Inhaltsverzeichnis: 1 The Function of the Historian in Society, 2 History Before 1950, 3 Experimental History, 4 BC AD CE BCE, 5 Heroic Values in Classical Literary Depictions of the Soul: Heroes and Ghosts in Virgil, Homer, and Tso Ch‘iu-ming, 6 Herod the Procurator and Christian Apologetics, 7 Herod the Procurator: Was Herod the Great a Roman Governor of Syria? 8 On the Dual Office of Procurator and Prefect, 9 Flash! Fox News Reports that Aliens May Have Built the Pyramids of Egypt! 10 Pseudohistory in Jerry Vardaman‘s Magic Coins: The Nonsense of Micrographic Letters, 11 More on Vardaman‘s Microletters, 12 Hitler‘s Table Talk: Troubling Finds, 13 Ignatian Vexation, 14 Pauline Interpolations, 15 Luke vs. Matthew on the Year of Christ‘s Birth, 16 Mark 16:9-20 as Forgery or Fabrication, 17 The Nazareth Inscription, 18 Thallus and the Darkness at Christ‘s Death, 19 Origen, Eusebius, and the Accidental Interpolation in Josephus, Jewish Antiquities 20.200, 20 The Prospect of a Christian Interpolation in Tacitus, Annals 15.44. Ich fand 12, 14, 15, 16 besonders informativ und spannend. Wissenschaftler und Laien kommen dank der übersichtlichen Schreibweise gleichermaßen auf ihre Kosten. Wem es zu ausführlich bzw zu akribisch wird, kann zum nächsten Absatz oder zur Zusammenfassung am Kapitelende springen. Bücher von Carrier sind überhaupt sehr zu empfehlen, besonders On the Historicity of Jesus, Not the impossible faith, The scientist in the early Roman Empire, Science education in the early Roman Empire, Why I am not a Christian.
P**B
Small doses of Carrier’s awesomeness.
Awesome collection of Carrier’s work and papers! If you like these, you’ll like his more extensive works in his other books.
B**K
Kompetent!
Das Buch enthält in 20 Kapiteln kleinere Schriften Richard Carriers, die zwischen 1995 und 2013 veröffentlicht wurden. Zu jeder Schrift gibt es Erläuterungen und erforderliche Korrekturen, sofern die damals zugrunde gelegte Faktenlage sich zwischenzeitlich änderte. Die Themen reichen von einer kurzen Einführung in die Arbeitsweise eines Historikers über Hitlers "Tafelgespräche" bis hin zur römischen Geschichte und den ersten Ansätzen zu späteren Publikationen bezüglich der Historizität der Figur "Jesus Christus". Das Werk ist lesenswert, und zeigt sehr schön die Methodik wissenschaftlicher Arbeit auf. Es ist allerdings ein sehr wissenschaftliches Buch, das für Leser, die sich mit der Materie nicht akribisch auseinandersetzen wollen, nicht wirklich geeignet sein dürfte. Wer eher an populärwissenschaftlichen Werken interessiert ist, ist sicher bei anderen Autoren besser aufgehoben - Richard Carriers Stärke ist seine Akribie und sein Eingehen auf Details, die dem Laien höchstwahrscheinlich unverständlich bleiben werden. Also - uneingeschränkte Kaufempfehlung für an Details interessierte Leser, Finger weg für Freunde der Populärwissenschaft und Belletristik.
Trustpilot
2 months ago
3 weeks ago