Eyelash Extension Mascara with Waterproof Mascara Base & Liquid Eyeliner with Waterproof Eyeliner Base Volumizing Mascara Makes Your Lashes POP Safe to Use with False Lashes & Sensitive Eyes

This mascara is very good at darkening the lashes and adding a little length and a little volume. I would like to see more of each length and volume for me to give it 5 stars. It is very black and doesn't flake or smudge throughout the day. It did not cause any irritation. I have very sensitive eyes since having lasik so I have to be careful about using certain mascaras on it. This one is fine for my sensitive eyes. The brush is not too fat or too skinny, I think it's just right for a mascara brush. I did not notice any odor. I have very blonde lashes and this did a good job of making them very black.The liner is really great! I would give it five stars for sure. You can get a nice thin line with it. It is easy to apply, I am not very good at applying eye liner because my hands are very shaky but I was pretty darn pleased with the way I was easily about to apply this. The best part about it is that it stays on like no other! I tested it on my hand and used soap and water to try to remove it and it did not budge. I was able to remove it with no issues with an oil based cleanser.Both the mascara and the liner came off my eyes with an oil based cleaners without any issues.A great thing I noticed on the package is that it is made in the USA. So many cosmetic products are made in China these days I just do not even know if I can trust them. I feel better knowing this is made in the USA. I am not sure if these two products are cruelty free. I posed this question on amazon but no one answered it. I could not find any information about it online when I was researching it.I feel these are a great deal for both the mascara and liner. They work as well as high end brands, if not better. I am a makeup product junkie and have tried tons of mascaras and liners and these are definitely comparable. I am attaching photos of how I was able to apply the liner and how dark the mascara made my very blond lashes. I was sent these products for free to test and review.Update - I have an answer to the cruelty free question. It's is cruelty free! YAY!

I used the instructions as directed: just a bit on the tips; however, it clumpled them up quickly (it did not give them a coat while separating them) and within minutes of putting it on, so many of my lash extensions started falling out. A day later, I had lost more than half of my lash extensions (it was as if the formula of the mascara and liner loosened up the glue completely). I do not recommend for lash extensions or for normal use. The eyeliner does not work, even if you try to shake the ink towards the tip; it goes on clumpy and gritty if at all. Worst Amazon buy ever.

First - no wear and tear on your lashes or lids when removing product; the mascara and eyeliner come right off with soap and water or makeup remover. No need to coat your eyes with oil.The mascara works great with the Lancome booster. Lashes separate and are long. Tossed out all my other mascaras. This is perfect.Liquid eyeliner glides on my eyelids easily with pencil thin line I can add on to for width if I want.

The product itself wasn't bad as a generic mascara (or liner). It had a very nice dark black color and applied easily. Brush was "ok" as well.But if I'm rating this mascara as "eyelash extension mascara" as it is described ..... then it is not as good.When having extensions, if you want to use a mascara it has to be very easily removed or you end up with residual on your extension possibly causing your lashes to come out during your next fill.Or...When you attempt to remove the mascara, if it doesn't just easily rinse or wash off without scrubbing, you will make the extensions come off during cleaning.I found it to be too difficult to remove. It requires a little more than water or needs scrubbing. Even when I used oil free remover there was still residual mascara on my lashes. So sadly, I can not use this product with my eyelash extensions.I had a hard time deciding what star ranking this should receive. So I averaged my feelings regarding a generic mascara being a 4 star. Or being an eyelash mascara as a 1 star.

I don’t have sensitive eyes and I don’t wear contacts, but the eyeliner burned my eyes like crazy. It made me want to dig and scratch my eyelids, it made them swollen and then a day later my skin started falling off...almost like the product burned my eyelid skin! I couldn’t wait to get home and wash it off my face but by that time it was too late. With that said, I really liked the eyeliner and the mascara was just okay. The eyeliner did stay and not smudge. It also dried extremely quickly. If it wouldn’t have bothered my skin I would have given it 4 stars, but the mascara did clump fairly easily.

Hands down best eyeliner I have ever used. Easy to use, not too shiny, pin point tip, comes off easily if your one wing comes up looking like Walmart. Mascara is great as well. A little difficult to get off of lash extensions but I don't expect it to be easy.... extensions are tricky like that. You wanna scrub them but you risk breaking them off. If you use your fingers to lather the make up remover it comes off better than using a wand. Anyway very happy customer here, especially cause I've tried a million eyeliner pens & hated all of them..

This product is perfect for the girl with eyelash extension or even sensitive eyes like myself. I tried this on my natural lashes and it was perfect, especially the quality. The mascara is none smudge and flake free. If you wear eyelash extension you can't use just any mascara, this mascara it meant for the eyelash extensions because its gentle enough so you can protect the longevity of your extensions. I also notice that the mascara is lengthening. The eyeliner is super black and waterproof and works great on natural lids before your eyeshadow placement.

Le eye-liner ne fonctionne pas du tout. Il est sec et ne laisse presque pas de couleur en plus de grumeaux. Il ne glisse pas du tout sur la peau! Très deçue de mon achat. Update, je n'arrive pas a voir mon remboursement, on me demande de retourner l'article a mes frais pour m'en renvoyer un autre...

The mascara is good, especially to use on fake lashes in between fills, but I was expecting the eye liner to come as well.. which I never received?

I only got the mascara, it was said I would have the mascara AND the eyeliner, I expect to be refunded or you ship the 5 eyeliners that are missing.

I have just received my second tube of mascara. I absolutely love it and it does not affect the longevity of my lashes.

Ordered twice and both times I did not get the eyeliner.