Makeup Lash Paradise Waterproof Mascara, Voluptuous Volume, Intense Length, Feathery Soft Full Lashes, No Smudging, No Clumping, Black, 0.25 Fl Oz (Pack of 1) Packaging May Vary

I have been using the L'Oreal Mascara line for over 15 years and I wouldn't trade it for the higher end products if you paid me to. I don't stray from what works for me and when it comes to makeup the drugstore brands can be far superior to the high end brands and mascara is one of them. I love this new line of mascara because at 43 my eyelashes have thinned out and this product gives me the volume I want. The only negative side is that this line tends to dry out quicker and can get clumpy and thick so you have to buy it more often but I love the effect. Great waterproof mascara for your buck! Easy to take off with Lancome's Bi-Facil makeup remover. I highly recommend it! You only need to use a little and it lasts me at least a year or more.

Truly love this. Doesn’t clump or smear.

Great mascara, it’s fully waterproof as indicated and easy to remove with oil. It does come out with some clumps, which is annoying to have to wipe away something you paid for. I’m not sure why they can’t design it to be a tighter inner squeeze chute so to speak, so you don’t have the loss and clumps coming out every time you use it. For that reason, I may research a different brand to try next time.

This was a great price. I was on vacation so I applied and it still looked new after 4 days. Goes on a little wet so I use an eyelash curler to minimize coats. Keep an eyelash comb handy. Does not come off with soap and water or makeup remover wipes. I use Garnier micellar water

This is my favorite mascara. Waterproof and thickens. I’ve tried many different brands and styles, and I keep coming back to this one.

This mascara clumps! So disappointed. I took it on vacation which is why I can’t return it because the Window closed on returns while I was away but I bought a new mascara while I was away. Not happy with the product much at all.

My favorite waterproof mascara. Just wish I could find it on a brownish black.

Still waiting to test it on an emotional day. But I only use waterproof mascara. And I've been rotating between Better Than Sex and Stila's waterproof mascara which are both about $20. This formula, however, glides on much smoother and does make my lashes look longer. Do they look like some of the commercials....no...but they do look longer than the previous two that I formulas I usually use. I have seen a bit of transfer when I use setting spray but no transfer or smudging later in the day so far. It does take a bit more scrubbing to get off which is surprising considering the formula looks thin and smooth. But honestly, I don't mind it because after all, all I really want is my mascara to stay put.