ColorStay Micro Easy Precision Liquid Eyeliner, Waterproof, Smudgeproof, Longwearing with Felt Tip Applicator, 303 But First, Wine, 0.057 fl oz

This is one of my favorite eyeliners ever. The color is gorgeous and is perfect for blue or green eyes. Sometimes, the formula can separate in the bottle, but it always has worked well if I remember to shake it before using it. The applicator is very thin but holds product well, making it easy to draw sharp wings or stay close to the lash line. If you use it every day, the product does go quickly, but it's worth the price you pay for it and more! Easy to use, dries quickly, and non-irritating to the eyes (even if you accidentally get it directly on the eyeball which I don't recommend anyway). I've also never known it to smudge or stay sticky. Love this stuff and I hope it always stays in stock.

Stays on well; Have no eye irritation and is water resistance. Such a great value and of good quality, I just purchased some more.

This is my go to liquid eyeliner. 🙌🏽🙌🏽 It’s easy to use, does not clump up or crepe up on your eyelids. The color is sharp and the bottle lasts a long time. I have it on a monthly subscription since it’s so affordable. It’s great for oily eyelids, does not smear as the day goes by. The tip is very skinny so you can have the sharpest cat eye. 10/10 highly recommend! ⭐️⭐️⭐️

Thin brush but color is too light for me

Great help for keeping eyeliner that I am spin

This product is not as expected as far as the color. From the name (What The Fudge) and the picture, I expected at least a medium coppery brown, if not darker. There are no other brown selections shown. I like the applicator as well as the longevity, but the color is a vibrant coppery red that I wouldn’t think would be flattering to anyone, especially me. I would recommend the product in other colors perhaps, but definitely not this one.

Applies smoothly and lasts all day. Happy with this purchase!!!

What the Fudge is not brown as you would expect. It is a light glassy-like copper color which makes your eyes look swollen and watery.

La punta ayuda perfecto al delineado si no eres experta y dura bastante no se corre ni nada pinta hermoso se nota y cambia tu vista y tus ojos totalmente para bien claro

This eyeliner is simply amazing. The pigmentation is a deep, intense black, and it’s very easy to use because the brush is soft, making it effortless to draw on my eyes. It’s long-lasting and stays on all day without smudging. This is the third eyeliner I’ve bought this year because I love it so much!

Muy buen producto, el aplicador me gusta mucho, es muy preciso

I love this eyeliner. It stays on all day, does not smudge or go away with teary eyes. I will definitely buy it again. My favorite eyeliner so far.

The colour brings out hazel eyes well and is easy to use. The line is thin, slightly plastic feel. It goes on a little bit more shiny than I would like and dry at the end of the stroke. But these are all standard for an eye liner in this price range.