- Candy Sampler Box – as Low as $.91 per Ounce - Build Your Own Artisan Candy Gift Box with over 40 Flavors – Fresh Creamy Homemade Fudge Variety – Custom Fudge Treat for Holidays, Birthdays, Thank You Gifts

This is the best fudge. Melts in your mouth. Very sweet. Highly recommend.

This fudge is absolutely delicious. It’s creamy and melts in your mouth. I keep it in the refrigerator so when I pull it out, it isn’t quite so soft, but that only means it is very fresh. It’s interesting that this fudge doesn’t spoil, it just slowly hardens over time. That was written inside on the card sent with the fudge. 📸 SEE PIC of my little piece of fudge cut thru the middle. ➡️ My only complaint is the brown half of the mint chocolate fudge seems to only be chocolate. Whereas the green half is definitely the mint. I tend to nibble on fudge and not bite off a humongous chunk so I feel like I’m only getting 1/2 of a minty experience. The green isn’t swirled into the brown part as much as it should be. It would be amazing if they put in just a little bit of mint into the chocolate half of the bar. Or better yet give me the choice to order a solid green bar of fudge, which would then be all mint. 🤤😃😍

It arrived on a warm day very soft but firmed up in the fridge. The chocolate cherry was delicious but the English toffee was too sweet.

I have ordered from this fudgemaker once or twice a year for the past few years, and their fudge is always delicious! This last time I got their fudge in my mailbox, I could have sworn I smelled it all the way from inside the house! I have my favorite flavors down to a science: Milk chocolate to get started, Cookies n' cream for that holiday sugar high, and regular chocolate to ween myself off until it's time to order again! By the way, the cookie pieces in the cookies n' cream are soft like the fudge itself, which is good because I have sensitive teeth! Highly recommend!!

Was unpleasantly surprised by all the "bad" ingredients in this fudge. Texture was velvety, but had a grainy sugar after taste. Lots of flavor choices, though. I say it's definitely worth it to spend extra and get a wonderful Mackinack Island fudge with all real ingredients and skip this brand.

I have ordered from them multiple times and always receive fresh mouth watering fudge. They have so many different flavors! The packaging is excellent and very handy for keeping it fresh. Personally I always order three different flavors and enjoy many happy bells as I eat them over time. I really recommend their product.

Quality

This product was bought for a restaurant competition for dessert tables. We were unable to use the fudge as it had melted all over the inside of the box! The manufacturer did not package their product correctly and now refuse refunds because I can't return it - who in their right minds would keep a box of melted fudge in their home? Amazon also refuses to post this review because it wasn't based on product quality! Well, the fudge was in an inedible state, that directly comments on quality! Buyer beware! Bad product from a bad company!