Marcelle Waterproof Eyeliner, Electric Blue, Hypoallergenic and Fragrance-Free, 1;2 g, 0;04 oz

I normally can't wear eye makeup due to severe allergies but I was able to wear this and had zero irritation.

This is my favorite brand of makeup out there. I've been using their products for a few years ever since trying a beauty subscription box. It stays on your face all night and doesn't smudge. You can even wake up the next day to roll out of bed and it's still there. It's one of the easier eyeliners to use. It's smooth and doesn't scratch your eyes. I'm going to end up getting a few other colors too! Even better, Amazon's price is really awesome as normally it's even more expensive.

I gave this 2 stars only because I really loved the metal green color! That’s the only positive about it , however!Cons:1. This is NOT at all hypoallergenic! The first time I wore it, I noticed that my eyes were slightly red that night, but thought maybe it was the ragweed pollen floating around. By the third time I wore it, I couldn’t even wait to get home to take it off! I grabbed a wet wipe and removed it ASAP! Red, very itchy, watery eyes! I waited a couple days and decided to try it around the house, but it only lasted a few minutes before I had another allergic reaction.2. It smudges really easily.3. It doesn’t stay on long.I’m returning it!

I only used it once just to see if it would irritate my eyes. It didn't. Also I wore it to bed and it mostly stayed on and didn't leave black circles under my eyes. i don't wear eye makeup often so I can't say if it would hold up if i cried or rubbed my eyes, etc.

I purchased this pencil in green. It's a nice shade of green and was easy to apply. I'm older, so I'm real particular about eyeliner pencils. If they pull or tug in any way, I won't use them. If they don't deposit color properly (some drug store brands and department store brands are awful this way), I return them. This went on easily and lasted just as long as the other brands that I've used. It's much cheaper than the brand that can be purchased in Ulta or Sephora that comes in an array of colors and performs at the same level for me. I'll buy this brand again.

I know how to do more eyeliner but I couldn't figure out how on earth to get more out of this! The end is plastic which means it shouldn't need a sharpener but I pulled, pushed, twisted, banged, hit, swore at and nothing ever worked to get anything to twist or push or pull to get more out. So I ended up throwing it away and spent twice as much for thrive causemetics eyeliner, but at least i KNOW i can get more out and 2-it will stay put and not give me raccoon eyes within 3 hours. NY eyeliner did that. Easy to put on but raccoon eyes, which is why I bought Marcelle, because i was tired of that. I want easy to put AND no racoon eyes. And also, easy to twist and get more when I use it.

I liked this liner, but it is not waterproof on my eyes. I do have very sensitive, teary eyes, and initially the color is vibrant. It fades on me quickly and must be reapplied during the day.

I bought his based on the reviews I read and they have got to be for a different eyeliner because this one is HORRIBLE....it does not stay at all. I worn it for an an hour then I looked in the mirror I looked like a raccoon. Super disappointed. Would never repurchase.

Ok so usually I'm a black eyeliner girl but have mixed it up with greens so I thought I'd try purple.Things to know:- it's like a cream liner so the color isn't bold, and as a matter of fact I'm still debating on whether or not it looks like purple eyeliner or my eyes have bruising around them.- as soon as I got the cap off it caught the tip of the liner and lopped it off, so I had to sharpen it right away and there will never be a fine point on this thing, it's like drawing in your eye with a tiny marble.- I have sensitive eyes and so far it's living up to the hypoallergenic promise.- it was almost all off my eyes in just a couple hours, definitely not long lasting.All in all, I'd recommend an actual pencil or liquid liner for actual colors. Or maybe start with black and use this one on top of that for the butterfly look.Update: tried at 3 different times and its barely noticable.

The eyeliner is a beautiful shade of purple but it's a bit too bright. I was looking for something a little more toned down but it's amazing if I blend in some black eyeliner with it. I like that I can get creative with it and make different shades of colours by mixing it with other colours. The eyeliner is smooth and rich and lasts a long time so it's fine by me. I don't like that it smudges a bit and clumps of it can set on the eyelashes.

It is closer to an olive green than I expected, I kind of was looking for something with a more blueish hue to it. It looks good with my hazel eyes and it does glide on well and doesn't smudge much so I'm still happy with it. It is also a nice base for the translucent shimmery ones that are popular for the holidays too.

thought it was a gel one but still works great been looking for so long to find this colour as bonnie bell discontinued it just an awesome eyeliner plus my sensitive eyes haven’t reacted would highly recommend

When I used this eyeliner for the first time, my eyes turned pink and I got an allergic reaction. At that time I thought it was due to something elseThen I wore this eyeliner again after 1 week and I got the same very irritated pink eyes, it appears that I am allergic to this product (I got my eyes checked by the doctor)