Petcakes Cat Birthday Cake Kit 859989002778 Diy Healthy Frosted 3 Small Fish Pet Cake, 3.5" X 1.5" X 1"

I give this 5 stars because the idea of this product is so cute, and I really wanted to make something special for my furbaby’s birthday. I’ll be honest though, I’m pretty sure the failure was on me, not the product. The prep process felt like a bit of a hassle, and I got frustrated, so I ended up giving it to my cats without fully finishing it or adding the icing. They still ate about a fourth of it, which is a win in my book. The smell wasn’t great, but cat food rarely is, and the day was about her, not me. If I buy it again, I’ll make sure to follow the steps correctly because the concept is adorable and the included tray mold is actually really useful. Worst case, I can use the mold to shape regular canned pâté into cute little fish shapes and top it with treats.

Even though it was easy to make, it smelled horrible. I fought through the smell because it was my boys first birthday and I was excited for them to have a cake. It crumbled as I took it out but I still frosted it. We lit the candle it came with, sang an incredible rendition of “Happy Birthday” and blew out the candle. I would have let the boys do it but they are still too little to be playing with fire! We set down their plates and waited for them to devour it only to have them sniff it and walk away. It’s a very cute idea but maybe work on the flavor. Side note: it’s a waste to open a can of pumpkin for 1 tablespoon.

My cat turned 1 yesterday, so i decided to make a cake for her and i found this product. It's easy to make and the instructions are pretty clear. But after it's done, my cat who eats everything won't even lick it, and her older brother won't even come near it even if i put their favorite tuna. At least we got to take a picture and it's kinda cute, even if we have to throw it away after because they won't even licked it. For me it's such a waste of money. And it also smells nasty if we didn't put the tuna. The smells came from the package mix, it's not like cat food smell or anything related, it's kind weird.

These were so quick and easy to make. We used them for my cats one year home celebration and they were perfect. My cats can be picky with foods, so I wasn’t expecting either of them to like it. We decided to put treats on top as eyes and in hopes of luring the cats in. The celebratory girl didn’t want to try the cake, but her brother loved them. We had no issues with the microwave smell others are mentioning. I only came across one minor problem. I did have to cut the tops and edges because they came out uneven, but that was an easy fix. Also, it came with a candle, which we did not use and comes with a tray that can be reused! Overall, so cute and very affordable compared to other cakes. Made our little celebration feel complete. Even if both cats didn’t like it I’d still recommend for the aesthetic. They really make the occasion feel special and are the perfect centerpiece.

Our cat absolutely loved these little cakes. We gave him half of a cake at a time over several days, mixed with some gravy. The packaging is easy to open, and the instructions are clear. It was easy to make the mixes, we used a tiny bit more water for the icing than the packaging recommended to make it easier to spread. I will say, the odor of cooking them was strong. Highly recommend leaving your microwave open for a while afterwards to air out and let it dissipate. Once they're out of the microwave it's not bad in the open air, but our microwave definitely had a funky smell for a little bit afterwards. Our cat liked the cakes initially, but they are a bit dry and unwieldy (for a little dude with no thumbs haha), so we actually cut the half cakes into smaller pieces and mixed in a little bit of gravy to soften it up. He LOVED that. Very cute product. Worth a try! And cheap enough that if your cat is picky and doesn't like them it's not a huge loss.