Lune+Aster Plum Dawn to Dusk Gel Eyeliner - 14-Hour Smudge-Proof, Waterproof, Semi-Matte Finish

I love this gel pencil liner and use it daily in different colors. Because the end is a soft crayon like gel, it goes on easily, but it also needs sharpening frequently to keep the point sharp. It's pretty easy to remove when you first put it on, but once on, it stays there. I have tried others, but never found one that stayed on like this one.

This eyeliner is my favorite! It stays on all day and does not smear. I have lots of trouble with smearing as I have deep set eyes. Love it!

Eyeliner doesn’t drag, stays put, comes in many colors and, doesn’t smear - my favorite eyeliner

It's water proof, it stays all day but it's hard to make a cat eyes with fine line and You have to keep sharpening it. It's over priced when you have to keep sharpening it

Great formula; easy to apply. Great coverage. Easily the best pencil eyeliner I've tried in a long while. The color (navy) is also a beautiful deep navy; exactly what I wanted. I can't five star it for two reasons: first it is smaller than I'd have liked for the price. Second, while the pencil came sharpened , the sharpened product broke off as soon as I tried to apply it which forced me to sharpen again and use more before I could even try it. With daily use I expect this will be gone within the month. Summary: great product for someone with deeper pockets.