Zuke'sPuppy Naturals Dog Treats Lamb & Chickpea, 5 Ounce (Pack of 2)

I purchased these to start clicker training with 4 week old puppies. I chose them due to the fact that the package and the product description touted them as being soft. The are NOT soft, I couldn't break them with my finger nails and the puppies couldn't chew them. My adult dogs loved them however.

Neppy (short for Neptune) is an Australian Shepherd puppy and she loves these treats.

Puppy loves this treat. However we’ve been advised by our vet to avoid legume ingredients for dogs. Chickpeas, peas and other grain-free fillers may lead to enlarged hearts in dogs over time.

My Puppy LOVES THE TASTE!!!

My puppy loved the treats, but we go through them pretty quick and it gets expensive very quick.

My dog likes these and I like the ingredients. Will buy these again.

My dogs liked the Zukes Mimi naturals, but they really favored the Blue Buffalo Mimi’s better

my dog refused to eat any of these treats.