Birds of Europe, North Africa, and the Middle East: A Photographic Guide Paperback – 7 Feb. 2017

Book is an excellent identification guide. I little heavy for the rucksack

Good book , pictures and details clear

The book covers every bird you could imagine in quite some detail. The illustrations and pictures are clear and descriptions are precise.That said with so much to cover the book is quite substantial in both thickness and weight. I'm not sure I'd want it in my backpack all day.

Excellent guide

Very pleased with this purchase

This guide has an extensive listing of birds but is a bit on the heavy side to carry in a pocket and is more of a reference book. The one missing feature are distribution maps for each bird.

This is a surprisingly under-discussed book in the British birding scene given that it is probably the best photographic field guide available to the birds of Europe. In fact, it may well be the only photographic field guide in English to cover every bird recorded in Europe. It is also for a number of reasons, one of the best field guides to Europe even in comparison with the traditional guides which use illustrations. Its judicious use of images and clean style will, I think, further accelerate the shift towards using photography in field guides. For me personally, this book is a game changer as this is the first book I have seen which would leave me happy with using a photographic guide in the field in Britain and Europe rather than one of the excellent illustrated guides which are available. The cover title is slightly confusing as I do not believe the book is not intended to be a comprehensive guide to all the species recorded in Europe, North Africa and the Middle East. The outside back cover clarifies that it is a guide to all 860 species to have been recorded in Europe and that it ‘….includes every species from North Africa and the Middle East to have occurred in Europe…..’. I wonder if it would have worked better in the British market if the cover had been titled as a ‘Complete Field Guide to the Birds of Britain and Europe’ and emphasising it covers every species recorded in Europe. Its focus on comprehensive coverage of every species recorded in Europe is a huge plus, a point obscured in the reference to Middle East and North Africa in the title. With this book, you don’t need a guide that covers the regularly recorded species plus one or more books that cover the rarities that may have been recorded just once or a few times.An overriding theme with this guide is that it is clean and simple and points you immediately to the key identification characteristics of a bird. It is probably the ‘cleanest’ guide to European birds. It is also the easiest on the eye of the field guides I have seen with this level of expertise permitting advanced identification. In recent years, I have been joining many of the birding and wildlife walks organised by the London Bird Club, a section of the London Natural History Society. These walks are often joined by beginners. I have found it helpful to have a field guide to help beginners compare and contrast similar species. More recently, I have been leading walks as well, thus making it even more important to have a user-friendly field guide to hand. The book of my choice has been the excellent Mitchell Beazley Bird Watcher's Pocket Guide by Peter Hayman, as the text is not overpowering; just enough to reinforce the key details and relies on many carefully thought out illustrations to point out the key field characters. It is also unbeatable in being compact. In fact, I prefer to carry the first edition (still available very cheaply in the second-hand market) of this on my walks in the UK, although I also have the expanded later editions which have grown into ‘The New Birdwatcher's Pocket Guide to Britain and Europe’. The ‘Jiguet’ is several times bigger at 467 pages vs. 192 pages, and with a page area twice as large, making it the same shape and size as the well-known Collins Bird guide. However, it has a number of advantages that in my view will compensate for a heavier book (compared to the Mitchell Beazley), when I lead walks and need to point out features to participants.Unlike many other field guides, it is beautifully simple without an intimidating wall of text. It is what I describe as a ‘visual read’. Take for example the page that distinguishes Arctic Tern from Common Tern. With many field guides, you have to read a chunk of text and process in your mind what the key field characters are. In this book you read the key characters almost entirely visually as the ‘pointer lines’ next to the images (a feature popularised many years ago by Roger Tory Peterson) takes your eye to the features you need to look at. In a matter of seconds you can absorb the key characters. Although I love my large collection of field guides with illustrations, I get the impression that beginners find photographic images easier to digest as they somehow seem more real. Even for experienced birders, I think this highly visual approach with bite-sized captioned text is very effective. The additional text is sufficient to understand the distribution and frequency of occurrence. But text is not so heavy as to make the book feel daunting. The way the birds have been shown with the backgrounds faded out with a lot of white space also makes the book easy on the eye. Another thing that helps is that the images are judiciously chosen to illustrate key characters that really do matter. There are a lot of images which for some species, but one never feels overwhelmed.This seeming lightness on the eye and mind hides behind it great expertise. A huge amount of effort would have gone into sourcing the right images. Although there are now a number of online image databases that make the task easier, finding the right images still remains a project in its own right. I should know. For John Beaufoy Publishing I authored and lead photographed a field guide to the Birds of Sri Lanka. It was a less ambitious project than this and for many species I used just a single image to illustrate a bird and used the succinct text to highlight the identification images. Even with the search for images considerably narrowed down, I still spent several months sourcing images from 58 photographers from 19 countries. In this book, almost everywhere, the authors have sourced the right suite of identification images for the birds. However, this is not to say there is no room for improvement. Coal Tit (not a rare bird) lacks an image which shows the white stripe on the nape. There is also a case for including more images showing the progress of plumage for the 3 year and 4 year gulls.Another factor that may mask the level of effort behind this is the succinct text. Having written a field guide to birds myself, I know only too well that several hours spent poring over advanced papers may only result in one carefully constructed sentence in an identification oriented guide. That appears very much the case with this book as it is apparent that many years of experience of advanced birding coupled with a good review of the identification literature has resulted in this to-the-point text.The book is 467 pages long with a slim introductory section (pages 6 – 11) which includes a page on plumage topography. Given the expertise underlying the book I was surprised that there was not a fuller discussion on moult and the plumage variations of birds such as gulls which may take up to three or four years to reach full adult plumage. Most species are covered with two species per page allowing enough plumage variations to be shown at a comfortable size. Some of the ‘difficult’ birds such as some birds of prey receive a full page. Nearctic vagrant passerines are three or more to a page. There is an index but the usual end pages such as a bibliography are missing. I don’t know if this was included in the original French edition published in 2015.I think this book is a serious option for anyone from beginner to advanced. Serious birders will still want a copy (even if only as a reference copy on the book shelf) of the Collins Bird Guide by Lars Svensson and Killian Mullarney. This has the same shape and size and weight. It has far more illustrations than the number of photographs in the Jiguet, which makes it more densely packed. Again, this raises the issue of the level of content vs. comfort for the user. Each birder will have their own parameters. British birders may also want ‘Britain's Birds: An Identification Guide to the Birds of Britain and Ireland’ by Rob Hume et al published by Wild Guides for a more British context as well as for the extensive collection of images in that book. Furthermore, this book does not do away with the need for serious birders to have books like the Helm Identification Guide. For getting to grips with gulls, an excellent book like Dominic Couzen’s ‘Birds ID Insights: Identifying the difficult Birds of Britain’ will remain invaluable. The serious birders will want them all on their shelves.I have been field testing this book and I have noticed a positive reaction from others. Some people have photographed the cover to order their own copy. On a Sunday in November, I gave the book a little test at the London Wetland Centre where at the Headley Hide I was treated to seeing a female Sparrowhawk catching a Common Snipe and bringing it back and perching close enough to be photographed well. I looked up Sparrowhawk to see if the book provided clear pointers to determine the sex of the bird. It did. I also then looked up Robin as I had taken some amazing close photographs of a habituated bird. It had what one would expect, but also interestingly, it carried an image of the ‘Canary Islands’ Robin. Something I would have missed with a book whose focus was purely on Britain.The choice of a field guide is a subjective choice with a few, very good books on the market. The clean design of this book, its focus on identification of difficult species, its ease of use and coverage of every bird recorded in Europe (up to 2017) makes this a strong contender for anyone looking for a field guide for use in Britain and Europe.

Good book