JW Pet Hol-ee Roller Dog Toy Puzzle Ball, Natural Rubber, Medium (4.5 Inch Diameter), Colors May Vary

My Boston Terrier didn't like this toy at first. We tried to get her engaged with it but she basically ignored it for a few months. Then one day she nosed it around and brought it to me for fetch. Ever since it's been her favorite toy. It's lightweight, bounces a bit when thrown, it's not loud, decent to play fetch and tug, indoor and outdoor friendly, she can easily carry it and squish her face into it. Since it doesn't have much surface area, it never feels very slobbery. The vanilla scent is not obnoxious. I like it better than the weird rubber smell that a lot of toys have. Really just pluses all around. She loved the small size so much that I ordered a large sized too. She loves them both, often trying to bring both at the same time to play.Update: It's been sometime since my first review, our little Bostie is full grown at 15 lbs now and she might be obsessed. The large size is just small enough for her to carry/run with. Both sized balls are now THE toys. They are the first toys she goes to every day. She takes them outside with her, makes us wait at the door while she goes and gets one even. She follows us in the house with them in her mouth, pressing them into our legs when we stop moving. They are really never far out of reach. We throw them for fetch, but she really likes to drop them as she's running back so they roll to your feet and you kick them! A lot of our fetch games turn into kickball fetch (which is a nice break for the arm!). These balls lob really nicely off your foot, even indoors it's relatively safe (use common sense, we don't kick them around breakables or screens). We've gotten creative and added smaller stuffed toys into the middle of the balls for her to pull out, or rolled fabric pulled though the holes (sometimes rolled with a little kibble or a few plain Cheerios or a couple high value treats). She's not exactly nice to them, but they are holding up very well, teeth punctures only, no tearing. I realize she's only 15 lbs, so obviously larger dogs may tear the material quicker/easier, however the rubber is really stretchy and seems to take a beating. She puts her whole weight into tugging, multiple times per day, and we've had no problems even with those sharp new teeth she has. These will also be fantastic at the dog park this summer! We found the Giggler version locally and it makes strange noises that intrigue her when she rolls it (it's a little heavy for kickball/fetch though, it's usually in the yard as a boredom stop for being alone). We got a football shape, but we think she likes the grip her mouth gets on the round style better as she doesn't play with it as much. I think we're JW Hol-ee Roller lifers though. I can't imagine another toy that our dog will like better at this stage in her life; we've tried just about every style available. She already has like 20 other toys she now ignoring for these! lol

My dog has had one of these toys since he was a puppy. He is now 12 and I had to buy his second one. Super durable for tough chewing dogs.

This is the second one we have purchased. The first one was the favorite toy of 3 giant breed aggressive chewing dogs over a period of 24 years. In all my years of having dogs I've never found a more durable toy that they actually loved, all on its own no treat needed. We bought this second one because after 2 decades of love and fun it had just started to show signs of cracking. That's truly impressive. Thank you for making such a great product, I'm looking forward to trying some of your others.

My Yorkies love this toy! This is my 3rd purchase of the same type of ball - the small 3" JW Pet HOL-lee ball. I bought one for my first Yorkie, she loved it, so when I got another Yorkie puppy, I bought a 2nd. They play with them so much that they sometimes get left outside. The green one was faded and started to blend it with the grass, so I bought a new one. It's great for a game of fetch, and isneasy to wash. Wish I could select a specific color, as I'd really like a purple one.

My doggie LOVES this ball, and will happily play fetch all day long. I've purchased it several times. It's lightweight, easy for her to hang on to, and washable. I do wish it could float. I took off 1 star because I received a red ball instead of the blue one I ordered-- not a big deal in this instance.

My golden and his dog park friends tug and tug on this plus run it over while trying to wrestly to fetch it. I have been worried it was going to rip or break because it feels cheap but I am actually very impressed. I have had it for a while now too. Its my dogs favorite ball.... and he is a golden retriever so he has many to choose from in our house so that says something

One of my dogs favorite toys! They’re pretty durable unless your dog is intent on tearing it apart. Indoors, outdoors, in the baby pool, in the ice, in the mud, you name it and it’s been through it. I also love the colors especially the aqua one that’s available. Also seeing their little teefers through all the holes is adorable.